Finger Lakes
Butler, New York
Butler is a town in Wayne County, in New York's Finger Lakes region, home to about 1,800 people as of the 2020 census.
Like the rest of upstate New York, an assessed value here usually isn't the market value; the state's equalization rate reconciles the two. The local rate is below, and the STAR program can lower the school-tax part of the bill.
- Type
- Town
- County
- Wayne
- Region
- Finger Lakes
- Population (2020)
- 1,835
Local Almanac
Notes in and around Butler
Short, sourced notes tied to this place, its county, or nearby communities.
This place · History & Culture
Butler Saved a Church and a Cobblestone Schoolhouse
Butler's history page turns local preservation into a story about an 1836 church, a cobblestone schoolhouse, and a bicentennial town.
Read this note ->Nearby · History & Culture
Wolcott's Story Runs Through Falls, Apples, and Lake-Plain Edges
Wolcott's town site frames the place through early settlement, Wolcott Falls industry, and a modern agricultural identity.
Read this note ->Nearby · History & Culture
Huron's lake edge has Shaker, canal, and orchard memory
Huron's official history turns a quiet Wayne County lake town into a story of Shaker land, canal hopes, orchards, and Chimney Bluffs.
Read this note ->Nearby · The Outdoors
Chimney Bluffs Gives Huron a Lake Ontario Edge
Chimney Bluffs State Park gives Huron a dramatic Lake Ontario edge of eroded spires, shoreline trails, and changing lake conditions.
Read this note ->Nearby · The Outdoors
Savannah Is Wayne County’s Wetland Edge
Savannah’s local identity is tied to the Montezuma wetland complex and the low, watery edge of Wayne County.
Read this note ->Nearby · Money & Taxes
Wayne Assessment Rolls Let Marion and Wolcott Owners Check the Annual Roll
Wayne County posts annual tentative and final assessment-roll routes, including town-specific links for Marion and Wolcott.
Read this note ->Nearby · History & Culture
Victory's name comes from a political win, not a battlefield
Victory's name, early tavern, mills, hotel, and old store corners make the town easier to remember than a quick map glance suggests.
Read this note ->Nearby · The Outdoors
Blind Sodus Bay pairs Wolcott beauty with shoreline checks
DEC's Blind Sodus Bay page makes Wolcott's bay setting useful and cautionary: shallow plants, invasives, and harvesting all matter.
Read this note ->Nearby · Money & Taxes
Wolcott Owners Can Use the County Roll Before Calling About Value
Wolcott owners can use Wayne County assessment rolls and PROS to check parcel and annual assessment details before calling.
Read this note ->Property tax snapshot
Roughly $17–$23 per $1,000
Combined full-value rate — county + town/city + school district, per $1,000 of market value (FY2025). On a $300,000 home that's about $5,122–$7,024 a year before the STAR break.
A planning estimate, not a bill. Your exact rate depends on your school district and any village. Confirm with the assessor.
Statewide links
Statewide starting points.
Good to know
- • Your assessed value usually isn't your market value — ask for the equalization rate.
- • Register for STAR; new applicants generally receive a credit instead of an automatic exemption on the bill.
- • Outside the cities, check the well, the septic, and the FEMA flood map before you buy.
Nearby
Nearby places
Tax rates: NYS Dept of Taxation & Finance (ORPTS), Real Property Tax Rates and Levy Data by Municipality, data.ny.gov dataset iq85-sdzs. (FY2025). Population: U.S. Census 2020. Reviewed June 2026. Source data ->
Page feedback
Send a page note
Send a note about this page. The page address will be included automatically.
Page feedback
Send a note
This is for fixing the site: wrong details, unclear wording, broken links, outdated information, or useful local context.